16

Looking at the Tengwar script designed by Tolkien I feel a certain similarity to the unknown script of the Voynich manuscript: Many characters look very similar to others of the same script, and there is a restricted set of penstrokes used in the characters. Repetition of strokes is used to derive other characters.

So I am wondering whether the Tengwar script could be influenced by the script of the Voynich manuscript. Was Tolkien aware of the Voynich manuscript? Or, to the opposite, was Tengwar already designed before the Voynich manuscript was rediscovered and publically known?

Improve this question

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
11

Or, to the opposite, was Tengwar already designed before the Voynich manuscript was rediscovered and publically known?

The manuscript was rediscovered in 1912. Tolkien, according to Wikipedia, started developing Elvish in 1910 or 1911... before the Voynich manuscript was rediscovered.

There is at least one claim that he was aware of it, though, although it would have to be after he had already started developing the languages.

This is a transcript of a message sent to the Voynich mailing list, sent November 13, 2002:

Hello
I have "lurked" on this list for a while and finally have a comment to offer, albeit a very insignificant one.

I wonder if the fact that Prof. JRR Tolkien apparently had an interest in (or at least knowledge of) the Voynich Ms has been discussed or indeed is of any interest at all?

The thing is, a nagging feeling that I had once seen the VMs many years ago - long before my recent interest was sparked by that piece in The New Scientist - is resolved. I now recall it - and though the persons concerned having died long since makes my little anecdote mere hearsay and in no way veridical, I thought I'd forward it. An old friend, a retired military man with an amateur interest in codes and cyphers, once showed me a couple of not entirely distinct b&w copies of pages from a curious coded manuscript, which I now realise were a couple of folios of the VMs. I was not especially interested in them at the time, I think, but the reason that the incident made an impression was that he said that they had been given to him by Prof JRR Tolkien. At that time I had just discovered and was very much 'into' Tolkien so I was most envious of my friend's knowing him and pressed for details of the great man, though in the end I never achieved my longed-for personal introduction. So I now wonder if there might be any reference anywhere in the mass of Tolkien papers to our VMs, and is this of any possible slight significance? After all, JRRT knew a great deal about languages and artificial scripts of course and if he was interested enough to make and pass on copies to a friend, he might have devoted some time to the VMs himself. And the Voynichese script does have a Tolkien-ish look to it or vice versa: could it have influenced him?

(this was found through a link from CipherMysteries.com)

However, since his development started before the Voynich manuscript was discovered, I'd say that it's... kinda unlikely that he was inspired by it.

Improve this answer
2
  • 4
    I think the languages are older than the scripts, and Tolkien had another script for the Elvish languages before Tengwar. Great quote, anyway, +1
    – Sir Cornflakes ♦
    Feb 21, 2018 at 14:08
  • 2
    Did a little googling and you're right, @jknappen, Tolkien used at least two other scripts before Tengwar -- sarati in the late 10s and Valmaric in the early 20s -- with Tengwar not appearing until the late 20s/early 30s. These scripts change and evolve into each other as Tolkien refines them over time, so it's still certainly possible Tolkien saw and was influenced by the Voynich manuscript during the decades he spent developing these scripts.
    – Sparksbet
    Jul 12, 2018 at 21:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.